Drug resistance and extended-spectrum β-lactamase (ESBLs) - producing Enterobacteriaceae, Acinetobacter and Pseudomonas species from the views of one-health approach in Ethiopia: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Abayneh, Mengistu; Zeynudin, Ahmed; Tamrat, Rahel; Tadesse, Mulualem; Tamirat, Abraham

doi:10.1186/s42522-023-00088-z

One Health Outlook

Table 1 General characteristics of included studies (2014- 2022)

From: Drug resistance and extended-spectrum β-lactamase (ESBLs) - producing Enterobacteriaceae, Acinetobacter and Pseudomonas species from the views of one-health approach in Ethiopia: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Study region	Study Year	Publication Year	Study Design	Sample size	Sources and types of samples	Method	Positive samples	References
Human related studies
Amhara	April 1 to July, 2018	2020	CS	238	Multiple clinical specimens from patients with nosocomial infections	Phenotypic	20	Motbainor H, et al., 2018 [20]
Amhara	March to June 2019	2020	CS	153	Sputum samples from patients with respiratory conditions	Phenotypic and genotypic	78	Abda EM. et al. 2020 [21]
Amhara	Dec. 2017- April 2018	2021	CS	833	Multiple clinical samples from different infection sites	Phenotypic	141	Moges F. et al. 2021 [22]
Amhara	2011 to 2014	2017	RCS	575	Multiple clinical samples from different infection sites	Phenotypic	280	Mulu W. et al. 2017 [23]
Amhara	January to May 2017	2020	CS	166	Blood specimen from puerperal sepsis post-partum/aborted women	Phenotypic	56	Admas A. et al. 2020 [24]
Amhara	Feb. to April, 2020	2021	CS	254	Multiple clinical specimens from patients with nosocomial infections	Phenotypic	33	Mekonnen H, et al. 2021 [25]
Amhara	Feb.–Aug. 2021	2022	CS	423	Multiple clinical specimens from patients with nosocomial infections	Phenotypic	75	Tilahun M. et al., 2022 [26]
Addis Ababa	March and Dec. 2017	2021	Cohort	119	Blood specimens from newborns with gram-negative sepsis	Phenotypic	119	Solomon S, et al. 2021 [27]
Addis Ababa	June, 2019 to May, 2020	2021	CS	1,337	Multiple clinical samples from different infection sites	Phenotypic	429	Abdeta A, et al. 2021 [28]
Addis Ababa	Oct. 2016 to Sep-2017	2019	CS	996	Multiple clinical samples from different infection sites	Phenotypic	135	Bitew A, 2019 [29]
Addis Ababa	Sep. 2018 to Jan. 2019	2022	CS	2397	Blood samples from patients with blood stream infections	Phenotypic and genotypic	597	Seman A. et al. 2022 [30]
Oromia	May to Sep., 2016	2018	CS	197	Multiple clinical specimens from patients with nosocomial infections	Phenotypic	118	Gashaw M. et al. 2018 [31]
Oromia	April 2016 to June 2018	2022	CS	684	Multiple clinical samples from different infection sites	Phenotypic and genotypic	65	Tufa BT., et al. 2022 [32]
South Ethiopia	Five-year (2016–2020)	2022	RCS	581	Multiple clinical samples from different infection sites	Phenotypic	237	Ageru TA. et al. 2022 [33]
Environmental studies
Amhara	May 2016-Aug 2016	2021	CS	110	Leafy vegetable samples	Phenotypic and genotypic	23	Cherinet Y. et al.2021 [34]
Amhara	January-June 2012	2014	CS	60	Hospital environment waste water samples	Phenotypic	51	Moges F. et al. 2014 [35]
Amhara	Dec. 2020 to Mar. 2021	2021	CS	384	Swabs of hospital contact surfaces, leftover drugs and 80% ethanol	Phenotypic	102	Firesbhat A, et al. 2021 [36]
Addis Ababa	Jan. to April 2019	2021	CS	572	Swab samples from HCW mobile phone	Phenotypic	454	Araya S. et al. 2021 [37]
Addis Ababa	June to Sep.2018	2020	CS	164	Hospital environment swab samples	Phenotypic	141	Sebre S. et al. 2020 [38]
Addis Ababa	Feb. to April, 2017	2018	CS	94	River water samples	Phenotypic	90	Belachew T. et al. 2018 [39]
South Ethiopia	Feb. to April,2021	2022	CS	120	Hospital Indoor air samples	Phenotypic	120	Kayta G, et al. 2022 [40]
South Ethiopia	May to June, 2018	2021	CS	99	Swab samples from hospital contact surfaces	Phenotypic	71	Birru M, et al. 2018 [41]
South Ethiopia	Nov 2014 to Feb,2015	2016	CS	120	Hospital Indoor air samples	Phenotypic	120	Hailemariam M, et al. 2016 [42]
South Ethiopia	Dec. to April,2015	2017	CS	216	Hospital Indoor air samples	Phenotypic	67	Solomon FB. et al. 2017 [43]
Tigray	Oct. 2016 to June 2017	2019	CS	130	Swab samples from hospital contact surfaces	Phenotypic	115	Darge A, et al. 2019 [44]
Studies on animal or food of animal origin
Oromia	April to June, 2018	2021	CS	140	Fresh chicken dropping from poultry farms	Phenotypic	61	Bushen A, et al. 2021 [45]
Amhara	Feb. to Mar., 2012	2014	CS	44	Poultry wastes from poultry farms	Phenotypic	52	Eyasu A. et al. 2014 [46]
South Ethiopia	Sep. to Dec. 2020	2022	CS	556	Raw cattle meat and meat cutting equipment at butcher houses	Phenotypic	36	Worku W. et al. 2022 [47]
Addis Ababa	Aug. 2019 to July 2021	2022 Unpublished	CS	642	Cow’s raw milk from dairy farms and milk selling points, Meat/carcass swab of cattle, sheep, goat, and chicken from butcher houses, supermarkets and abattoirs and animal feed samples from feed manufacturing plants	Phenotypic	185	Tefera B, et al. 2022 [48]
Oromia	Dec., 2013 to May, 2014,	2020	CS	384	Samples from caecal contents of chicken	Phenotypic	56	Asfaw Ali D. et al.2020 [49]
Amhara	Feb. 2014 and Dec. 2015	2016	CS	384	Egg sandwich, minced and raw meat, burger patties, cottage cheese, cream cake, and beef pizza from restaurants, cafeterias, and pastry and retail shops Raw egg and pasteurized and raw milk from supermarkets and retail shops	Phenotypic	21	Ejo M, et al.2016 [50]
Addis Ababa	Dec. 2014 to April 2015	2016	CS	280	Lung and liver swab samples from bovines and ovines slaughtered at abattoir house	Phenotypic	13	Kebede A et al. 2016 [51]
Addis Ababa	Aug. 2011 to April 2012	2014	CS	384	Meat samples of animals from abattoir and retailers shops	Phenotypic	39	Bekele T et al. 2014 [52]

Back to article page

ISSN: 2524-4655

Contact us

Submission enquiries: claire.argote@springernature.com
General enquiries: info@biomedcentral.com