Skip to main content

Table 6 Subgroup analysis of prevalence estimates of Salmonella and pathogenic E. coli strains in human stool and the associated risk factors in Ethiopia

From: Prevalence and epidemiological distribution of selected foodborne pathogens in human and different environmental samples in Ethiopia: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Risk factors

Subgroup

Prevalence (95%CI)

Ï„2

I2

Q (P value)

Age group

Under five children (UFC)

6.4(4.1–8.9)

1.10

95.8%

665.4(<  0.01)

under 15

4.7(2–10.6)

1.10

81.7%

32.8(<  0.01)

Adult

4.2(2.6–6.7)

1.10

78.3%

87.4(<  0.01)

All age group

4.2(2.1–8.1)

1.10

92.7%

137.2(<  0.01)

Stool condition

Diarrheic

5.6(3.9–7.5)

1.20

94.8%

840.1(<  0.01)

Unidentified

7(2.8–16.1)

1.20

96.0%

125.9(<  0.01)

Non-diarrheic

3.3 (1.8–5.8)

1.20

76.5%

63.7(<  0.01)

Administrative regional states or city council

Amhara

4.2(2.4–7.1)

1.19

97.1%

592.6(<  0.01)

Oromia

5.5(2.5–9.2)

1.19

80.9%

52.5(<  0.01)

SNNP

3.8(2.1–6.7)

1.19

78.0%

68.3(<  0.01)

Addis Ababa

8.1(4.4–14.2)

1.19

93.7%

189.9(<  0.01)

Dire Dawa and Harari

6.6(2.6–15.9)

1.19

84.8%

26.3(<  0.01)

Others

3.4(1–11.1)

1.19

80.7%

15.5(<  0.01)

Geographic area

Northwest Ethiopia

3.6(2–6.4)

1.22

97.3%

559.9(<  0.01)

Central Ethiopia

7.6(4.6–12.1)

1.22

92.8%

264.8(<  0.01)

Southern Ethiopia

3.4(1.6–5.5)

1.22

80.0%

70.1(<  0.01)

Eastern Ethiopia

6.6(2.5–16.2)

1.22

84.8%

26.3(<  0.01)

Southwest Ethiopia

5.7(2.4–12.9)

1.22

79.2%

28.8(<  0.01)

Others parts of Ethiopia

4.9(1.6–14.3)

1.22

76.4%

12.7(<  0.01)

Study area (town or district)

Northwest eth areas

3.8(1.3–10.6)

1.05

87.8%

32.8(<  0.01)

Other

4.7(1.4–8.5)

1.05

82.8%

0.3(<  0.01)

Hawassa

2.1(0.9–4.5)

1.05

47.0%

15.1(<  0.06)

Addis Ababa

8.1(4.6–13.8)

1.05

93.7%

189.9(<  0.01)

Central Ethiopia areas

6.6(2.4–17.1)

1.05

95.4%

65.1(<  0.01)

East Ethiopia towns

6.6(2.7–15.2)

1.05

84.8%

26.3(<  0.01)

Gondar

1.1(0.4–3.2)

1.05

0.0%

3.9(<  0.43)

Bahir Dar

7.7(3.4–16.2)

1.05

98.6%

359.2(<  0.01)

Jimma

5.8(2.6–12.4)

1.05

79.2%

28.8(<  0.01)

South Ethiopia area town

7(3.3–14.3)

1.05

71.8%

21.3(<  0.01)

Publication year

2016–2020

4.8(3.3–6.5)

1.22

90.2%

450.2(<  0.01)

2011–2015

6.1(3.6–10.2)

1.22

97.2%

573.8(<  0.01)

2000–2010

3.9(1.4–10.5)

1.22

84.7%

26.2(<  0.01)

Actual study year

2011–2015

7.3(4.9–10.8)

1.07

95.6%

594.3(<  0.01)

2016–2020

4.2(2.8–6.1)

1.07

87.8%

236.9(<  0.01)

2006–2010

2.9(1.2–6.9)

1.07

90.3%

51.5(<  0.01)

2000–2005

5.1(1.7–14.2)

1.07

77.5%

13.4(<  0.01)

Study design

HFB R-s

7.9(2.7–20.4)

1.15

91.8%

48.6(<  0.01)

HFB CS-s

5.6(3.9–7.5)

1.15

94.9%

880.1(<  0.01)

IB Cs-s

3.6(2–6.5)

1.15

80.6%

61.8(<  0.01)

CB Cs-s

2.2(0.5–9)

1.15

69.4%

6.50.04

Diagnostic technique

C–Gs and Bt

4.7(3.3–6.3)

1.26

91.8%

575.6(<  0.01)

C– Bt and ser

5.9(3.4–9.9)

1.26

96.7%

510.4(<  0.01)

Molecular

6.3(0.7–39.7

–

–

–

Sample size

≤100

7.9(3–18.9)

1.32

69.4%

19.6(<  0.01)

101–200

5.1(3.2–7.9)

1.32

89.1%

229.8(<  0.01)

201–300

4.4(2.5–7.6)

1.32

92.7%

220.2(<  0.01)

 

301–400

2.8(1.2–6.3)

1.32

89.9%

69.6(<  0.01)

 

> 400

7.5(3.1–13)

1.32

98.5%

525.5(<  0.01)

  1. UFC under five children, HFB CS Health facility based cross sectional study, CB CS community based cross sectional study, IB CS Institution based cross sectional study, HFB ret. health facility based retrospective study, mixed = stool samples collected from both Diarrheic and Nondiarrheic participants, SNNP Southern Nations, Nationalities, and Peoples